Opens in a new tab
How mature is your risk management?
Take the Free AssessmentTake Assessment

Risk Management

Bowtie Analysis: How to Build a Bow Tie Diagram for Risk Management

Bowtie analysis is a risk assessment method that maps, in one diagram, how a hazard could lead to harm and the barriers that stand in the way: threats and prevention on the left, consequences and mitigation on the right, the top event at the knot. The diagram is only the start. Its value comes from knowing which barriers are critical, whether they still work, and how each one connects to the controls and indicators in your risk register.

Keith Ricketts-Clew-GRC

Keith Ricketts

November 12, 2026
Time to read: 10 minutes

Summarize this article with:

ClaudeChatGPTGoogle GeminiPerplexityGrok
2
sides to every bowtie: prevention on the left, mitigation on the right
7
steps to build one, including the step most guides leave out
1
top event per bowtie, which keeps each diagram readable
Didn't have time to read - TL;DR
3 key takeaways
1

A bowtie shows what stands between a hazard and harm. Threats on the left, consequences on the right, and the barriers that stop or soften each one, in a picture anyone can read.

2

The diagram is the start, not the finish. Most bowties are drawn once and pinned up. The value comes from knowing which barriers are critical and whether they still work.

3

Connect it to the register. Each top event is a risk, each barrier is a control, and each critical barrier deserves an indicator.

The bowtie analysis workshop ran for two days in March. Twelve diagrams came out of it, each with a hazard at the top, threats on the left, consequences on the right and a neat row of barriers in between. They were printed, laminated and pinned up in the site office.

By October, three barriers on the most important bowtie had changed. A contractor had replaced the lock-out kit. The shutdown roster had doubled the number of isolations per shift. The second-person check had quietly stopped. None of it reached the diagram or the risk register. The bowtie still showed six good barriers. In practice there were fewer, and one of those was under strain.

That is the gap in most bowtie work. The method is excellent at showing what should stand between a hazard and harm. It says nothing on its own about whether those barriers are still standing. This guide covers what bowtie analysis is, the parts of a bow tie diagram, a worked example, seven steps to build one, and how to connect each barrier to the controls, evidence and indicators that keep it honest.

What Is Bowtie Analysis?

Bowtie analysis is a risk assessment method that maps, in one diagram, how a hazard could lead to an unwanted event and what that event could lead to. The barriers that prevent the event sit on the left; the barriers that limit the damage sit on the right. The diagram takes its name from its shape: threats fan in from the left, consequences fan out to the right, and the event sits at the knot in the middle.

It is used widely in high-hazard industries such as aviation, rail, mining and energy, and increasingly in enterprise risk management, because it shows what stands between a hazard and harm in a way a board can read at a glance.

The Parts of a Bow Tie Diagram

Every bowtie is built from the same seven parts.

  • The hazard is something with the potential to cause harm, such as stored energy in plant under maintenance.
  • The top event is the moment control of the hazard is lost, such as a loss of isolation, and it sits at the knot.
  • Threats are the causes that could lead to the top event, and they sit on the left.
  • Consequences are the outcomes if the top event happens, and they sit on the right.
  • Preventive barriers sit between each threat and the top event, and stop it happening.
  • Mitigating barriers sit between the top event and each consequence, and limit the damage.
  • Escalation factors are conditions that weaken a barrier, such as time pressure, and each one needs its own control.

Illustrative bowtie from this guide. Critical barriers are outlined in orange.

Bowtie Analysis Example

The diagram above maps one scenario: a loss of isolation while plant is being maintained. Three threats could lead to it: isolation not applied, stored energy not released, or the wrong equipment isolated. Each threat has two preventive barriers. On the right, three consequences follow, from serious injury to regulatory action, each with at least one mitigating barrier.

[SME SIGN-OFF REQUIRED: example bowtie, barriers and critical controls]

BarrierSideWhat it addressesCritical?
Permit to workPreventiveIsolation not appliedNo
Personal lock by each workerPreventiveIsolation not appliedYes
Energy release procedurePreventiveStored energy not releasedNo
Try-test before work startsPreventiveStored energy not releasedYes
Equipment labellingPreventiveWrong equipment isolatedNo
Second-person verificationPreventiveWrong equipment isolatedYes
Emergency stop within reachMitigatingSerious injury or fatalityNo
Emergency responseMitigatingSerious injury or fatalityNo
Automatic overload shutdownMitigatingDamage to plantNo
Prompt notificationMitigatingRegulatory actionNo

One escalation factor is shown: time pressure during shutdowns, which tempts crews to skip the try-test. Its control is supervisor sign-off on every shutdown permit.

How to Do a Bowtie Analysis in Seven Steps

Most guides stop at six steps, when the diagram is drawn. The seventh is where the value is.

1. Define the hazard and the top event

Name the hazard precisely, then the moment control of it is lost. The top event is not the harm itself; it is the point just before harm becomes possible. “Loss of isolation” works. “Someone gets hurt” is a consequence.

2. List the threats

Ask what could cause the top event. Keep each threat specific and independent. Three to six threats keep a diagram readable; if you have twenty, you probably have more than one top event.

3. List the consequences

Ask what could follow if the top event happens. Include harm to people, damage to assets, environmental effects and regulatory or reputational outcomes, wherever they are credible.

4. Add preventive barriers

For each threat, list the barriers that stop it leading to the top event. A barrier must be able to interrupt the sequence on its own. Training and awareness support barriers, but on their own they rarely are one.

5. Add mitigating barriers

For each consequence, list the barriers that limit the damage once the top event has happened. These include emergency response, physical protection and recovery arrangements.

6. Identify escalation factors

For the barriers that matter most, ask what could weaken them: time pressure, fatigue, contractor turnover, a change of equipment. Add each escalation factor below the barrier it affects, with the control that manages it.

7. Assess each barrier

This is the step most bowties skip. For every barrier, record who owns it, how effective it is, and whether it is critical. A diagram that shows six barriers but cannot say which three matter most, or whether they still work, is a picture rather than an analysis.

A bowtie that never changes is a picture of the day it was drawn.

How to Run a Bowtie Workshop

Bowties are best built in a short workshop with the people who know the work, not only the people who manage it.

  • Invite the risk owner, two or three people who do the task, someone from maintenance or engineering, and a facilitator who knows the method.
  • Build one top event per session, and stop when every barrier is named, owned and assessed, not when the diagram looks complete.
  • Write down every disagreement about whether a barrier really works, because those are the first things to test.
  • Put a review date on every bowtie before the workshop ends.

From Diagram to Critical Controls

Not every barrier carries the same weight. A critical control is a barrier whose failure would sharply raise the chance or severity of the outcome, often because it is the only strong barrier on its path. In the example, the personal lock, the try-test and the second-person verification are critical: each one is the last reliable barrier before the top event on its threat line.

Effectiveness needs the same discipline. The UK Civil Aviation Authority’s bowtie guidance treats a barrier’s effectiveness as its adequacy multiplied by its reliability: how well it would work if used, and how consistently it is actually used. A strong barrier that is skipped on night shifts is a weak barrier in practice.

Critical control management, well established in Australian mining, builds on exactly this idea: identify the few controls that matter most, set a performance standard for each, and verify them in the field on a schedule. How to test a control’s design and operation is set out in how to assess control effectiveness.

Key distinction

A barrier on a diagram is a claim. A barrier with an owner, a performance standard and recent evidence is a control.

Connecting a Bowtie to Your Risk Register

A bowtie and a risk register describe the same risk from two angles. The bowtie shows how it could happen and what stands in the way. The register records who owns it, how it is rated and what is being done. Connect them, and each keeps the other current.

  • The top event becomes a risk in the register, written as cause, event and outcome, as set out in how to build a risk register.
  • Each barrier becomes a control on that risk, with an owner and an effectiveness rating.
  • Each critical barrier gets an indicator, such as the share of isolations verified on time, so drift shows up between reviews, as described in key risk indicators.
  • The residual rating on the risk matrix reflects the barriers as they are, not as they were drawn.

Keeping a laminated diagram and a spreadsheet in step is where most organisations lose the thread. Clew’s risk management software is built to hold it: the bowtie, the register and the controls behind each barrier live as one connected record, so a change to a barrier shows up against the risk it protects and the indicators that track it.

When to Use Bowtie Analysis

Bowtie analysis earns its time on risks where the consequences are severe and the barriers matter.

  • It suits major hazards, such as loss of containment, falls from height, vehicle interactions and loss of isolation.
  • It suits high-consequence operational risks with a clear top event, such as a critical asset failing or a key supplier collapsing.
  • It suits any risk the board asks about in the form “what stops this happening?”.
  • It suits less well diffuse strategic risks with many small causes, where a register entry and a few indicators do the job better.

Bowtie Analysis vs Fault Tree and Event Tree Analysis

Bowtie analysis is often described as two older techniques joined at the middle. The left side works like a simplified fault tree, tracing the causes that could lead to the top event. The right side works like a simplified event tree, tracing what could follow from it.

Fault trees and event trees can model probabilities and complex logic in far more detail, which suits detailed engineering studies. The bowtie gives up some of that precision for something more useful to most organisations: a single picture that operators, managers and boards can all read, with the barriers in plain view.

Common Bowtie Mistakes

  • Activities are listed as barriers. Training, awareness and meetings support barriers, but a barrier must be able to stop the sequence on its own.
  • There are too many threats. A diagram with twenty threats is usually several top events squeezed into one, and nobody can read it.
  • Barriers have no owners. A barrier nobody is accountable for is a barrier nobody checks.
  • The diagram is drawn once. Plant, people and procedures change, so review each bowtie when they do, and at least once a year.
  • The bowtie never reaches the register. If barriers are not recorded as controls with effectiveness ratings, the board never sees what the bowtie found.

A bowtie that avoids these mistakes becomes part of something larger: the traceable link from an organisation’s objectives through its risks, controls, actions and assurance to the indicators that show whether it is performing. The diagram shows where the barriers are. The rest of that link shows whether they hold.

Frequently Asked Questions

Bowtie analysis is a risk assessment method that maps how a hazard could lead to an unwanted event, what that event could lead to, and the barriers that prevent it or limit the damage. The diagram is shaped like a bow tie, with the event at the knot.

A bow tie diagram has a hazard, a top event, threats on the left, consequences on the right, preventive barriers between the threats and the top event, mitigating barriers between the top event and the consequences, and escalation factors that can weaken a barrier.

An escalation factor is a condition that weakens a barrier, such as time pressure, fatigue or a change of equipment. Each escalation factor sits below the barrier it affects, with its own control to stop it degrading that barrier.

Preventive barriers sit on the left and stop a threat leading to the top event. Mitigating barriers sit on the right and limit the damage once the top event has happened. A good bowtie needs both.

The top event becomes a risk in the register, each barrier becomes a control with an owner and an effectiveness rating, and each critical barrier gets an indicator. The bowtie shows how the risk could happen; the register shows who owns it and whether the barriers are working.

Put Your Barriers to Work

Clew is a risk and assurance platform built around the Golden Thread, so each barrier on a bowtie connects to the risk it protects, the evidence that it works and the indicators that show when it weakens. Risk and assurance teams in government, healthcare, construction, infrastructure and utilities, mining and resources, and transport use Clew to keep their risks, controls and indicators connected to the objectives they protect. See how that works in practice: watch the on-demand Clew walkthrough, or explore Clew’s risk management software.

Related Resources

Keith Ricketts-Clew Risk Software

Meet the author

Keith Ricketts

VP Of Marketing

25 years with global software vendors in Cyber Security, Risk and ERP. Blends strategic marketing, agility and a proven record of results.
Connect on LinkedIn

In this article

How mature is your risk management?

Take the free assessment and get a personalised report in minutes.
Take the assessment