Opens in a new tab
How mature is your risk management?
Take the Free AssessmentTake Assessment

Risk Management

Orange Book Risk Control Framework: How to Evidence the Four Pillars

How the Orange Book risk control framework works: five principles, four pillars, three lines and the Assurance Directory that replaced the bank of questions.

Keith Ricketts-Clew-GRC

Keith Ricketts

November 3, 2026
Time to read: 15 minutes

Summarize this article with:

ClaudeChatGPTGoogle GeminiPerplexityGrok
4 pillars
Sixteen blocks of control requirements accounting officers already carry.
3 lines
Underpinning every pillar, from managers who own risk to internal audit.
75 questions
The recommended minimum in Part 1 of the Assurance Directory.
Didn't have time to read - TL;DR
3 key takeaways
1

The Risk Control Framework adds no new controls. Part II of the Orange Book sorts the control requirements an accounting officer already carries into four pillars, underpinned by the three lines model. The work is proving those controls work, not writing new ones.

2

The public toolkit changed in 2025 and 2026. The bank of questions became the Central Government’s Assurance Directory in April 2025, and four supporting guides left GOV.UK in July 2026. The core text, the pillars and the Directory remain public.

3

Four steps turn the framework into evidence. Start with a principal risk, place its controls in the four pillars, map assurance across the three lines, then test the evidence. One risk done properly teaches more than a full spreadsheet done lightly.

Your Audit and Risk Assurance Committee (ARAC) meets in a few weeks, and it wants to know how this year’s comply or explain position is shaping up for the governance statement. Someone has to show the accounting officer that the controls behind it work, and under the Orange Book risk control framework that job usually falls to the second line.

So you open the Orange Book page on GOV.UK for the bank of questions you last used. It has gone. In its place sits a spreadsheet called the Central Government’s Assurance Directory, and four of the supporting guides have been removed.

None of that changes the task. Orange Book risk management starts with five principles. Part II goes further. It asks for something harder than a policy: proof that the controls you already have are working, in a form a sceptical committee will accept.

That comes down to four steps, worked through below on one principal risk, as the guidance stands in late 2026.

What is the Orange Book risk control framework?

The Orange Book risk control framework is Part II of HM Treasury’s Orange Book, added in May 2023. It sorts the control requirements already placed on accounting officers into four pillars, with the three lines model underneath. It adds no new requirements: it gives departments and arm’s length bodies a common structure for assuring the controls they already have.

Orange Book risk management: the five principles in Part I

Part I of the Orange Book sets five main principles. Part II builds on them, so they are worth having straight before you look at the controls.

  • Governance and leadership. Risk management is part of how the organisation is directed, managed and controlled at every level, not a separate activity.
  • Integration. Risk is assessed inside strategy, planning, options appraisal, programmes and performance management, not alongside them.
  • Collaboration and best information. Risks are managed across organisational boundaries, including arm’s length bodies and delivery partners, using the best available evidence and expertise.
  • Risk management processes. Structured processes cover identifying and assessing risk, choosing and implementing treatments, monitoring, and reporting in time to inform decisions.
  • Continual improvement. The framework improves through learning and experience. The supporting guidance adds a review at least once a year.

The main principles are mandatory and the supporting principles beneath them are advisory. Each organisation discloses compliance, or explains departures, in its governance statement. That comply or explain disclosure has been in the Orange Book and the Financial Reporting Manual since 2020.

Orange Book Part I vs Part II: principles and controls

Part I of the Orange Book sets the principles for how risk management should work. Part II shows where the control requirements sit, and how to evidence that they are met.

Part I: principlesPart II: Risk Control Framework
SetsFive main principles for how risk management should workFour pillars that sort existing control requirements
StatusMain principles mandatory, supporting principles advisoryNo new requirements
AnswersHow should risk be managed?Where do the controls sit, and how are they assured?
Evidence lands inThe comply or explain disclosureAssurance maps behind the governance statement

Part II adds no principles. It is a subset of the risk management framework, covering the “what” and “why” of control rather than the “how”, and it changes no accounting officer’s responsibilities. It grew out of a cross-government review led by Sir Nigel Boardman with the Risk Centre of Excellence, the Treasury Officer of Accounts and GIAA, the Government Internal Audit Agency. For the wider picture, see how a risk management framework gets used.

One clarification: the corporate governance code the Orange Book refers to is the code for central government departments, not the Financial Reporting Council’s UK Corporate Governance Code and what Provision 29 asks of listed company boards.

The four pillars of the Risk Control Framework

The Orange Book risk control framework groups the control requirements on an accounting officer into four pillars of four blocks each, with the three lines model running underneath:

  • Governance and Management Framework: each organisation has a governance framework that meets expected standards of conduct, efficiency and transparency.
  • Roles and Accountabilities: roles are defined and held by people with the seniority, skills and experience to carry them.
  • Strategy, Planning and Reporting: plans make the risks to objectives visible, and reporting is designed to support risk-based decisions.
  • Standards, Policies and Procedures: approvals and decisions follow delegations, financial controls, government policy and local procedures.
PillarIts four blocksEvidence an assurance team might look for (illustrative)
Governance and Management FrameworkPropriety and ethics; governance statement and accounting officer system statement; boards; arm's length bodies and joint ventureBoard and committee terms of reference, the evidence pack behind the governance statement, sponsorship reporting from arm's length bodies
Roles and AccountabilitiesAccounting officer; all staff; functional roles; senior responsible owners for major projectsNamed owners for each principal risk and its controls, SRO appointment letters, records of mandated training
Strategy, Planning and ReportingMedium-term planning; annual planning; processes; reportingPlans that name the principal risks to them, risk reports that show position against appetite and early warning indicators
Standards, Policies and ProceduresDelegations and budgetary control; functional standards; public sector and wider statutory requirements; organisational policies and proceduresDelegation schedules and exception logs, functional standard assessments, statutory compliance records, policy review dates

Treat the evidence column as a starting list, not a checklist. Under Strategy, Planning and Reporting, the real test is whether a report changes a decision, which is what directors actually need to see in a risk report.

The pillars sit at the top of a hierarchy. Central requirements, from Managing Public Money to the functional standards, act as entity-level controls across government. They inform each organisation’s local assessments, which shape the risks and controls managed at unit and process level. That is why one pillar can hold a statutory duty and a local procedure at once.

One caution on scope. The blocks come from central government requirements, such as accounting officer system statements and major projects. A department or arm’s length body uses them as written. An NHS body, council or college can borrow the structure, but several blocks will not apply. For how this plays out across different kinds of public body, see how Clew supports risk and assurance in government.

How the Orange Book three lines model underpins every pillar

Underneath all four pillars sits the three lines model, set out in Annex 2 of the Orange Book. It is the reason the Risk Control Framework is about assurance rather than paperwork.

  • The first line is management. It owns and manages risks, runs controls day to day and fixes deficiencies.
  • The second line is made up of the functions that oversee or specialise in risk. They set boundaries, monitor compliance and, through assurance teams, usually lead the assurance mapping.
  • The third line is internal audit, typically GIAA in central government, which gives an objective view of how well the first two lines work.

Outside the lines sit external assurance providers such as the National Audit Office and the National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (NISTA), which absorbed the Infrastructure and Projects Authority in April 2025. The Orange Book still uses the old name.

The point most readers miss is this: neither the board nor senior management is a line. They are the people the lines serve. The Directory’s quick guide cites the Institute of Internal Auditors’ 2020 Three Lines Model as its reference, so the language will be familiar to any internal auditor.

Count the board as a line of assurance and the map flatters itself.

What changed on the Orange Book page in 2025 and 2026

The core Orange Book text has not been substantively revised since May 2023. The material around it has. The GOV.UK change log records the following.

  • In April 2025, the bank of questions was replaced by the Central Government’s Assurance Directory.
  • In June 2025, a quick guide to the Directory was added.
  • In June 2026, the Directory was updated to its Spring 2026 edition.
  • In July 2026, four supplementary guides were removed as out of date: the Portfolio Risk Management Guidance, the Risk Appetite Guidance Note, the Risk Management Skills and Capabilities Framework, and the Good Practice Guide: Risk Reporting. A link to the Government Finance Function’s OneFinance intranet, which needs a login, was added in their place.

In practice, readers with a OneFinance login should use the current guidance there. Everyone else works from the core text and the Directory. Two loose ends remain. The HTML edition of the Orange Book, updated the same day, still lists the four removed guides as its supplementary suite, and Part 2 of the Directory still asks questions about them.

What is the Central Government’s Assurance Directory?

The Central Government’s Assurance Directory is a spreadsheet, owned by the Risk Centre of Excellence, that gathers the standards, codes and guidance issued by the centre of government in one place, with questions against each. It launched alongside Part II in 2023 as the Orange Book risk control framework’s bank of questions, introduces no new requirements and is updated each spring and autumn.

Its six parts cover the Orange Book principles, the other published Orange Book guidance, the framework itself, the functional standards, other standards, codes and guidance, and a set of spotlight items.

Two parts matter most. Part 1 holds 75 recommended minimum questions, covering the five principles and at least one question per framework component; it underpins the comply or explain disclosure. Part 3 holds key lines of enquiry from the Cabinet Office and GIAA for each pillar and block, a fair preview of what internal audit is likely to ask.

Of the four steps below, the Directory serves the second and the fourth. It does not hold the answers. The April 2025 edition of its quick guide leaves the level of evidence to each accounting officer and says it should be relevant, reliable, understandable and free from bias. The July 2026 HTML edition drops that passage, but the test still holds.

Key distinction

Questions versus evidence. The Directory supplies the questions. The answers, the evidence behind them and the date it was last checked are yours to hold.

Assurance mapping under the Orange Book: four approaches

Assurance mapping is how the three lines become something an ARAC can read. Drawing on HM Treasury’s 2012 assurance frameworks guidance, the Orange Book describes it as linking assurance from different sources to the risks that threaten an organisation’s objectives, so that its nature, coverage and depth match the confidence needed.

Section G names four approaches in use across government:

  • Principal risk based mapping starts with the risks to strategic success and maps assurance onto each one.
  • Process based mapping starts with a prioritised list of business processes.
  • Control based mapping starts with the organisation’s most important controls.
  • Risk assurance mapping uses the risk management process itself as the frame.

They overlap, they can be combined, and the Orange Book mandates none of them. Start principal risk based. The Orange Book’s own first tip is to start with what is strategic, and a principal risk is where the accounting officer’s attention already sits.

Four more of its tips are worth adopting from the start. Use the risk and control information you already hold. State what good looks like, and the quality of evidence required, before you look. Refresh the map every year. Keep it proportionate to the scale of the organisation.

How to evidence the Risk Control Framework in four steps

Here is the method, worked through one hypothetical principal risk: an arm’s length body running a frontline service that depends on one critical supplier. The risk comes from the Orange Book itself, which uses a failure to plan for third-party supplier and market failure as its example in Annex 5. Run the same method for each principal risk and, within one assurance cycle, you hold dated evidence against all four pillars. That is what evidencing the framework means in practice.

1. Start with a principal risk

Name the objective it threatens first: uninterrupted delivery of the frontline service. Then state the risk as cause, event and consequence, as Annex 5 recommends. Weak supplier management and no check on the supplier’s finances (causes) leave the body unprepared when the supplier fails (event), leading to service failure and higher costs (consequences).

2. Place its controls in the four pillars

Board oversight sits in Governance and Management Framework. Named contract and risk owners sit in Roles and Accountabilities. Supplier monitoring in performance reports sits in Strategy, Planning and Reporting. The commercial functional standard, delegations for contract changes and a continuity plan sit in Standards, Policies and Procedures.

3. Map assurance across the three lines

Control (illustrative)First lineSecond lineThird line or externalEvidence last checked
Supplier financial health monitoringMonthly contract manager reviewQuarterly commercial function checkIn internal audit planSeptember 2026
Continuity plan for the serviceAnnual exercise by service ownerResilience team reviewNoneNovember 2024
Delegations for contract changesApprovals logFinance compliance reviewTested by internal auditAugust 2026
Board oversight of the principal riskNoneRisk team deep diveARAC deep diveJuly 2026

4. Test the evidence

Ask whether each piece of evidence is relevant, reliable, current and free from bias, and whether it meets the standard of good you set in advance. Above, the continuity plan’s annual exercise last ran in November 2024, so its first line assurance is stale and nothing beyond the second line covers it. That becomes an action with an owner and a date. Then ask whether residual exposure still sits within appetite, which turns on where appetite ends and tolerance begins.

An assurance map without dates on its evidence is a list of good intentions.

You can run all of this in a spreadsheet, and the Orange Book leaves that choice to each organisation. The difficulty comes later: once the register, the control library and the assurance map live in separate files, they drift apart, and the evidence behind the governance statement goes stale between reviews. That is the case for purpose-built risk management software, and public bodies can shorten the procurement by buying risk software through G-Cloud.

Common mistakes with the Orange Book risk control framework

Each of these undoes one of the four steps.

  • Do not treat the Risk Control Framework as a new set of controls to write, because it is a structure for the ones you already have.
  • Do not answer the Directory’s questions without recording the evidence and the date it was checked.
  • Do not count three lines of assurance on a control without asking whether each one is any good.
  • Do not treat the board or senior management as a line, because that flatters the coverage.
  • Do not work from the old bank of questions or a supplementary guide that has since been removed.

Frequently asked questions about the Orange Book

The Orange Book is HM Treasury’s guidance on managing risk in government, titled Management of Risk: Principles and Concepts. Part I sets five main principles that departments and arm’s length bodies apply on a comply or explain basis. Part II, added in May 2023, is the Risk Control Framework, which structures existing control requirements into four pillars.

The five main principles are governance and leadership; integration; collaboration and best information; risk management processes; and continual improvement. Together they require risk management to be part of how an organisation is led, built into its decisions, informed by the best available evidence, run through structured processes and improved over time.

The four pillars are Governance and Management Framework; Roles and Accountabilities; Strategy, Planning and Reporting; and Standards, Policies and Procedures. Each holds four blocks of existing control requirements, from propriety and ethics to delegations and budgetary control. The three lines model underpins all four.

For central government departments and arm’s length bodies, the five main principles are mandatory, and each discloses compliance or explains departures in its governance statement. The supporting principles are advisory. Other public bodies are not bound by it, though the Orange Book notes it may be useful to them.

The Central Government’s Assurance Directory replaced the old bank of questions in April 2025. It is a spreadsheet owned by the government’s Risk Centre of Excellence, covering the Orange Book principles, the framework’s pillars and blocks, the functional standards and other central guidance. It is updated each spring and autumn and published on the Orange Book page on GOV.UK.

Not since the 2020 edition. Tolerate, treat, transfer and terminate come from the 2004 edition. The current text lists six options: avoid the risk, take or increase it to pursue an opportunity, retain it by informed decision, change the likelihood, change the consequences, or share it, for example through a contract. Many teams still use the 4Ts as shorthand, which works if the register records which option was chosen and why.

Management is the first line, owning risks and running controls. Functions that oversee or specialise in risk form the second line, setting boundaries and monitoring compliance. Internal audit is the third line, giving an objective view of the first two. Boards and senior management are not lines; the lines serve them.

Start with one principal risk

Before your next ARAC, take one principal risk through the four steps. Begin with the control whose evidence is oldest. If you cannot find, date and link that evidence in an afternoon, that is your first improvement.

The cross-government review that produced Part II ran as the Golden Thread project. Clew uses the same name for the chain this guide has followed: objective to risk to control to evidence to action, held in one place. Keeping that chain connected makes the Orange Book risk control framework easier to evidence year after year.

Clew keeps the register, the controls, the assurance evidence and the actions in one connected platform, with control assurance across the three lines and risk aggregation across a department and its arm’s length bodies. See how Clew connects risks, controls and assurance evidence.

Sources

Last reviewed: 3 Nov 2026.

Keith Ricketts-Clew Risk Software

Meet the author

Keith Ricketts

VP Of Marketing

25 years with global software vendors in Cyber Security, Risk and ERP. Blends strategic marketing, agility and a proven record of results.
Connect on LinkedIn

In this article

How mature is your risk management?

Take the free assessment and get a personalised report in minutes.
Take the assessment